Start free
← All posts

Pricing

How to set your shop's labor rate (and check what you really earn)

Your posted labor rate and the rate you actually collect are rarely the same number. Here's how to set the first and measure the second.

By , owner of Auto Star Garage and builder of Gearboxly

· 5 min read

How to set your shop's labor rate (and check what you really earn)

Most shops set their labor rate once, look at what the shop down the road charges, nudge it up a few dollars a year and hope it's enough. The trouble is that the posted rate is only half the story. What the shop actually earns per hour sold is usually lower, and nobody notices until the bank balance does.

The short answer: set your rate from your own costs and the profit you need, not from the competition, then track your effective labor rate every month so you know whether the posted number is surviving contact with real repair orders.

Start from your costs, not the shop down the road

Competitor rates tell you what customers in your area are used to seeing. They don't tell you what your shop needs. A shop with older equipment, a paid-off building and two techs has a very different cost per hour than a shop with a new lease and five bays.

Work it out the plain way. Add up a month of the costs that labor has to cover: tech wages and payroll taxes, the service writer, rent, utilities, insurance, software, tools, training and the owner's pay. Then estimate how many hours you can realistically sell in a month, not how many hours your techs are on the clock.

Here's a simple example. Say those monthly costs come to $48,000 and your techs sell about 400 hours a month between them. Your break-even labor rate is $120 an hour. If you want a 20% profit on labor, you need roughly $150. These are example numbers only. The point is that the rate falls out of your costs and your sold hours, and if either changes, the rate should too.

  • Total the monthly costs labor has to pay for, including your own salary
  • Estimate billable hours sold per month, not hours worked
  • Divide costs by hours to get break-even
  • Add the margin you need and round to a number you can say out loud with a straight face
A bright, clean repair shop floor with cars on two-post lifts
Your labor rate pays for the bays, the lifts, the tools and the people.

Posted rate vs. effective labor rate

Your effective labor rate is the labor you actually sold divided by the labor hours you sold. If you posted $150 an hour but discounted a few jobs, gave away diagnostic time and redid a couple of jobs for free, the effective rate might be well under $150.

Gearboxly reports show effective labor rate next to sales, car count and average repair order, so you can see the gap every month instead of guessing. If the effective rate is drifting down, the fix is usually not a higher posted rate. It's finding where the hours are leaking.

Tip: Look at effective labor rate by month, not by week. A single big comeback can swing one week, but a monthly trend tells you whether something has changed.

Where labor dollars leak

The same few leaks show up in most shops. Each one is small on a single repair order and expensive across a year.

  • Discounts given at the counter to close a sale, without a rule for when that's okay
  • Diagnostic time that never gets charged because the customer declined the repair
  • Comebacks fixed for free, which add hours with no sale
  • Labor times guessed low, or copied from the wrong engine
  • Jobs that took longer than quoted where nobody updated the estimate

Two of these are about lookups. When labor times show up for the exact vehicle as the writer types the job, there's less temptation to guess. In Gearboxly, the published hours appear under the job box as you type, and the job lands on the repair order at your labor rate. If you use a different labor guide, you can paste its rows in and the hours come across.

Should you have more than one labor rate?

Some shops charge a higher rate for diagnostic work, electrical, diesel or European vehicles, and a standard rate for maintenance and general repair. That can make sense if those jobs really do need more expensive tools, training or time. It also adds complexity at the counter. If you go this way, keep it to two or three rates and make sure your software applies them automatically, so the right rate isn't up to whoever is writing the ticket that day.

Talking to customers about your rate

Customers rarely ask what your hourly rate is. They ask what the job costs. Price the job, explain what's included and show the photos. If someone does ask about the rate, say it plainly and explain what it pays for: trained techs, proper equipment, a warranty on the work. People respect a straight answer more than a defensive one.

Related: Reports guide: effective labor rate and the rest of Shop Pulse

Review it twice a year

Put a recurring reminder on the calendar. Every six months, re-add your costs, look at your hours sold and compare your effective labor rate with your posted rate. If costs went up, raise the rate. If the effective rate is far below the posted rate, chase the leaks first. Small, regular adjustments are easier on customers than a big jump every few years.

The short version

Set your labor rate from your own costs and the hours you can actually sell. Then watch your effective labor rate every month, because that's what you really earn. Close the leaks (discounts, free diag, comebacks, guessed hours) before you reach for a higher posted number.

Try it on your own repair orders

14-day free trial. No credit card. No contract, cancel anytime.

Start free trial
Want our shop guides in your Google results?Add Gearboxly as a preferred source on Google

Keep reading

← Back to all posts